Custom Cookies made in New York. Buttery vanilla Shortbread cookies.Icing made with Marshmallows. All Products / Example Cookies - Birthdays All Products Allegra Bakes a Cake - The Book! Example Cookies - Decorated Example Cookies - Paint Your Own Example Cookies - Corporate Example Cookies - Birthdays Example Cookies - School sets Example Cookies - Bridal Example Cookies - Baby Shower Jack's 2nd Birthday - Moana themed Custom Cookies $0.00 Add To Cart Ezra's 'Thomas the Tank Engine' themed cookies $0.00 Add To Cart Henry's Fire Truck Themed Decorated Cookies and PYO Cookie sets $0.00 Add To Cart Rose’s 2nd Birthday Cookies $0.00 Add To Cart Olivia’s 4th Birthday Rainbow cookies $0.00 Add To Cart Brooks’ 2nd Birthday Race Cars $0.00 Add To Cart Sophie’s 3rd Birthday $0.00 Add To Cart Willow’s 1st birthday rainbow cookies $0.00 Add To Cart Laura's 4th Birthday Cake Cookies $0.00 Add To Cart Emma's 5th Birthday Rainbow Unicorn Cookies $0.00 Add To Cart Bertha's Eiffel Tower Birthday Cookies! $0.00 Add To Cart Dara's 5th Birthday Cookies! $0.00 Add To Cart